7/6/2015 10:41 AM | |
Joined: 7/2/2008 Last visit: 9/30/2024 Posts: 928 Rating: (309) |
Hello everyone, One of my customers has an S7-400H communicating with DCS through redundant Modbus RTU. The data to be transferred is almost 2 KBs (over 500 floating point values) He suffers from a slow update rate over the Modbus RTU (from 3 to 6 seconds) with 19200 bps. My first guess on this 3 to 6 seconds is the limited 16 bytes for data channel over Profibus. He sent me his existing network architecture with proposed solution from the package provider to add two CP443-1 with S7 open Modbus TCP Red and two gateways. Since I'm not a communication guy, I need to ask some questions. 1- Has anyone worked with such a configuration before? 2- Is Modbus tcp made for mass data transfer? I mean is it the right choice for the task? 3- Even if things get faster on the CP443-1 side, don't you think it will be still slow since Modbus is still limited to 125 registers per telegram. I mean there will be still a bottle neck in the DCS side (RS485 side) with several request to receive the whole 2Kbytes. 4- As far as I understand the gateways will act as slaves for the Modbus master and clients for the CP443-1 (servers) but is it possible to configure two clients for one server or should each client has only one server? 5- As far as i understood from him that the Modbus RTU masters are pulling data all the time and the DCS is managing the data redundancy. Will it work this way with S7 open Modbus TCP Red? Do we have active communication on both CPs all the time? Best regards, H-H AttachmentModbus RTU and TCP networks.pdf (945 Downloads) |
7/8/2015 5:12 PM | |
Joined: 7/2/2008 Last visit: 9/30/2024 Posts: 928 Rating: (309) |
Hello Kaulquappe, Thank you very much for your reply. I would like to clarify more things. In RTU redundant networks, the PLC acting as slave doesn't have any code to manage the redundant data. I mean it's just moving the required data to both CP341 and the DCS with RTU Masters is tho one who's taking care of redundancy and switching over. Will it be the same with Modbus TCP (If the H system is the server)?! Do both H-CPUs act as separate servers with two different IPs or single server? Do I have to configure the client in DCS to access two servers? Referring to the Modbus TCP PN RED wizard in the double sided connection and supposing my H station will be the server, does each client communicate to the two servers? What if the configuration is as per my attachment? Do I still have double sided connection in this case or two single sided? Once again thank you very much for your help. Best regards, H-H AttachmentModbus TCP - separate connections.pdf (756 Downloads) |
This contribution was helpful to1 thankful Users |
1/19/2017 8:07 PM | |
Posts: 3093 Rating: (323)
|
It is not possible to have two devices with an identical IP address in one net. IP addresses always must be unique. Regards, |
Follow us on